Name One Thing with Tracy Holt | Advice on Mentorship, Adjunct Teaching, and Co-authorship in graduate school

Banner image for the Name One Thing Series of Exclusive Interviews, providing sage advice for graduate student success. Image shows a graduate student in cap and gown, back to the camera, facing a blackboard and making a triumphant pose.


Name One Thing: Advice for graduate students from those who’ve been there.

Welcome to Name One Thing the interview series where I ask academics, researchers, postdocs, and other professionals what they wished they’d known when they were in in graduate school. Today’s guest is Mx. Tracy Holt, a senior statistician who shares vital wisdom on mentorship vs. advisement, cautions on adjunct teaching, and tips for successful co-authorship.

About Today’s Guest

Picture of Statistician Tracy Holt

Name: Tracy Holt (They/Them)
Degree: M.S. Mathematics, M.P.H.
Current role: Senior Statistician, focused primarily on Psychometrics for clinical research.
Find Them at LinkedIn: /tracy-holt-34870650/




1) Name one thing you wish someone had told you when you were a graduate student.

The importance of mentorship. The best researchers don’t always make the best mentors. It is more important to have someone who is interested in your professional development. During my first master’s degree, I didn’t know to look for any particular qualities, though I was fortunate and received some good mentorship. Unfortunately, I completed that degree in the middle of a recession. During my second master’s degree, I knew to look for that mentorship and found it in more than one place which helped prepare me for my career. In both programs, I had classmates who were with more prestigious researchers and had to work harder but didn’t receive good mentorship. These advisors did not seem invested in their student’s success, and it led to burnout for more than one.

Adjunct teacther points at a blackboard while reading from a book held in their other hand.

2) You have worked as an adjunct faculty member at a community college and a university. Name one thing you think graduate students should know about teaching as an adjunct.

Teaching as an adjunct is not a good pathway to being a full-time faculty member. While it can be an opportunity to develop skills in the classroom, I have known very few people who were able to go from teaching as adjunct faculty to full-time positions either at the same or other institutions. In my own experience, having four years of teaching experience between teaching as an adjunct instructor and as a G.A. instructor seemed to carry little weight when applying for full-time positions. There also may be very little oversight or guidance. I taught classes for both a university and a community college. At the community college, they provided that oversight and guidance, and I had a supervising faculty member who was there to guide me. With the university, any guidance that I received, I had to seek out myself. I don’t advise teaching as an adjunct as a primary career choice, or primary source of income, though it can be good to make some money on the side.

3) You have co-authored multiple peer-reviewed journal articles. Name one thing about the publication process that you think most graduate students are ill-prepared for.

Reviewers aren’t experts. They are people who have authored related research. Not all will take the time to understand your research. Some will provide useful feedback, but others will fixate on things that are less relevant. When I am revising publications, in many cases I make revisions to placate the reviewers even if I don’t think they are useful changes. In other cases, it may be sufficient to explain why the changes are either not appropriate or not plausible. One catch-22 is around statistical analysis. Ideally, you should do the analyses that are most appropriate for the context of your research which may not be what is commonly used in similar research. However, if you are not using what had commonly been used, you will have to be more rigorous in providing justification for using it. Reviewers will often challenge approaches they aren’t accustomed to seeing, whereas they will not question commonly used approaches even if they are less appropriate for the specific context of your research.


Thank you for sharing your insights with us, Tracy! I just had a similar conversation with Dr. Rios, over at the Grad Student Academy about the differences in mentorship and advisement with another graduate student. Many prospective Ph.D. students are starting to consider advisors as they prepare to apply to graduate programs this fall and this is such vital and timely information.

Wishing You All the Best in Your Academic Success.
Dr. Cristie Glasheen, Your Graduate Student Success Coach.


Admissions Coaching

Applying to graduate school? Want to maximize your chances for success? Check out our admissions coaching services. From strategy through acceptance, we’re with you every step of the way.

Master’s Degree Coaching

Want help earning your Master’s Degree? We can teach you everything from academic writing skills, to studying smarter not harder, to improved time management and productivity.

Ph.D. Coaching

Earning a Ph.D. or Professional Degree? Stressed to the max and not getting the support you need from your advisor? We can help! Just click the big pink button. It’s okay, we know you want to.

Master Academic Writing

Our unique document review services are part masterclass in writing, part editing service. We review your document with a critical eye and provide you with real feedback that you can apply to all of your academic writing.

M.H., Ph.D. Toxicology

Dr. Glasheen! I passed with barely any revisions requested of me. I am able to submit my dissertation tomorrow morning […]!
Thank you for all your help!

S.C., Professional Development Coaching

It’s so very evident how much Dr. Cristie cares about my progress and successes. It gets me through the hard days knowing how much she is genuinely routing for me. She’s gone out of her way to be responsive and supportive and help me get past the blocks I kept running into. She really did help get me unstuck and now I’m staying that way.

A.S., Ph.D. Epidemiology

I don’t know how other people who are balancing work and family manage to finish their dissertations without a coach, but I am so glad [other client] told me about you. This was the best decision I could’ve made. I’m so thankful.

F.N., Ph.D. in Environmental Economics

What’s been the most helpful? “Breaking down tasks that overwhelm me. Navigating many difficult decisions that are crucial towards achieving my PhD. Getting feedback on my work. And tracking the work in progress which is often invisible.”

“I think Dr. Cristie does an amazing job. I have tried the free coaching provided by my institution and I would rather pay Dr. Cristie.”

K.G., Ph.D. Public Health

Just got this in my email – [Dissertation] Approved with no restrictions! THANKS, COACH!

I.M., Ph.D. in Economics

What’s been the most helpful? “It has been useful to look at problems from a different/more helpful perspective. I like that I have been able to work on my thesis sustainably without burning out, considering that I have a full-time job. I usually feel very motivated to work on my thesis after the meeting with Cristie, and having weekly meetings helps me be accountable and drastically reduce my procrastination. I also really appreciate the knowledge sharing of resources and the work smarter, not harder approach (e.g. AI suggestions, Andy Stapleton videos, Focusmate, programs that help with identifying duplicates, etc).”

H.N., Masters in Public Health

Just want to appreciate the incredible Cristie and how wonderful of a mentor she is. I’d want to be your student and to learn from you over and over again! There’s absolutely no one half as good as you’re. Thank you for being a part of my journey. My heart is SO full now that I’m done with my degree and I reflect on the huge role that you played in making it true. What a gem!

G.G., Ph.D. Bioinformatics

I just wanted to let you know I successfully defended and will be graduating in a couple weeks!
Thank you again for all your help […]!

Alex, Ph.D. Environmental Science

Having Cristie as a coach was one of the best investments I made in graduate school. Period. She was instrumental in helping me pass my comprehensive exam and finish my research proposal, all while giving me the tools to manage two other projects I was juggling at the time. Despite being laser-focused and results-driven in helping me achieve my academic outcomes, Cristie is also very human and reminded me that graduate school is more than just academics and that you have to make time for yourself and for fun stuff.

A.M., Postdoc, Atmospheric Science

Hi Cristie, I just wanted to let you know that I finished my presentation on time… one day ahead of schedule! That’s a first for me. Thank you for your help keeping me on track with our coaching sessions!

A.S., Ph.D. Public Health

Finished! My dissertation was defended on 01-July and I am an official Ph.D.! What an incredible journey. I am so grateful for our interactions and still apply [your] lessons in life.

R.H., Admissions Coaching for Master’s Higher Education Admin

“Hi Dr. Cristie! (…)

I’m happy to report I got into all the programs I applied for!

  • [Redacted] University: fully funded, plus $24,000 stipend & health care (…)
  • University of [Redacted]: no scholarship offered, did not apply for GA positions.
  • [Redacted] University: offered 50% tuition, GA position offered up to 66% tuition. (…)”

*Some content redacted for privacy.

A.M., PhD Student, Economics

Successfully submitted my online [grant] application! It was an unknown journey for me, but what I now do know is that it was possible greatly thanks to you. So thank you so much!

A.S., Ph.D. Candidate, Industrial/Organizational Psychology

I PASSED [the oral comprehensive exams]. Thank you so so so so so much! I could not have done this without you! [redacted for privacy] I can’t believe it’s over […] The beginning of the end is finally here! I’m so happy!!!

T.N., PhD. Evolutionary Biology

I’m a doctor!!! Wooo! The presentation went well […]. Thanks so much for all of your help getting to this point! I really appreciate it!

K.H., Doctor of Physical Therapy Student

It has been a crazy semester but it is going really well. Just finished 2 of my courses and feel really good about them. I feel like I have been able to use so much from working with you the last year to make this semester go amazing.



Interview Disclaimer

We aim to share diverse perspectives and experiences. The views, opinions, and experiences shared by our guests in this interview series are solely their own. Their participation is not an endorsement of our services, products, or views, nor does it imply an endorsement of their services, products, or views by us.